Rail & Transit · Chicago, Illinois

Metra seeks $360 million to $380 million in Chicago rail upgrades if Union Pacific merger proceeds

A flyover at Proviso Yard and an underpass in West Chicago would keep commuter trains moving when freight trains cross their tracks. Metra also wants a binding 95% on-time standard on two lines.

Infraday News Desk · Based on official sourcesPublished
Two Metra locomotives stand on adjacent tracks at Chicago’s Ogilvie Transportation Center.
Metra locomotives 100 and 107 at Chicago’s Ogilvie Transportation Center on September 25, 2026. Phil Richards via Wikimedia Commons, cropped by AlphaBeta135, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Photo source

Metra asked the U.S. Surface Transportation Board on November 18 to reject Union Pacific’s proposed acquisition of Norfolk Southern. If the board approves the deal, the Chicago commuter railroad wants it to require two projects on the Union Pacific West Line. Metra estimates their combined cost at $360 million to $380 million and says it is willing to share the expense.

The dispute turns on what happens when a freight train crosses the tracks a passenger train needs to use. Metra says the merger analysis counts capacity along a route without adequately accounting for the minutes when a train entering a yard can block every track at once. The West Line, between Chicago and Elburn, and SouthWest Service, between Chicago and Manhattan, Illinois, together carry about 5.2 million passenger trips a year, according to the filing.

Where an extra track still leaves trains waiting

At Proviso Yard, west of Chicago, freight trains entering or leaving the yard can cross all three main tracks. David Kralik, Metra’s director of planning and programming, told the board that a long freight train can take up to 30 minutes to clear them. A commuter train held there can leave late again after it turns around for its next trip.

Metra has already contributed more than $47 million toward about eight miles of third track on the West Line. One completed piece, documented by the Chicago Region Environmental and Transportation Efficiency program, added 3.5 miles of track and a bridge over Addison Creek. An extra track gives dispatchers another way to move trains side by side. It loses that advantage when a freight train cuts across all three.

The proposed Proviso flyover would carry one passenger track above the freight route, allowing both trains to move at the same time. Kralik put the cost at $160 million to $180 million in current dollars, up from Union Pacific’s 2022–23 estimate of $125 million to $150 million.

At West Chicago, Metra proposes taking a passenger track underneath the junction with Canadian National. Kralik said the merger operating plan would send 10 to 12 additional freight trains a day through the junction. At about 20 minutes per crossing, he estimated that those movements could block the West Line for up to four hours in total over a day. Metra’s preliminary estimate for the underpass is about $200 million. The parties would still have to negotiate who pays what share.

How the 95% standard would work

Metra wants the board to measure on-time performance separately on the West Line and SouthWest Service, and separately on affected segments of the West Line. That detail matters to a rider whose train crosses Proviso every day. Better results elsewhere could mask a recurring delay at the yard. The West Line averaged 91.3% on time from July 2022 through December 2025, according to the analysis Metra filed.

Under Metra’s proposal, a rolling 90-day result below 95% would trigger a corrective plan if host-railroad freight operations materially contributed to the delays. Dispatchers could change freight time slots or train lengths, for example. Metra would keep those measures in place until the trains met the target for two consecutive quarters. If performance fell below 90% over the same period with freight again a material cause, Metra wants the board to review the problem promptly. It also wants the railroads to model actual weekday and rush-hour schedules before adding freight after a merger.

Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern argue that combining their networks would reduce handoffs and save shippers an estimated $3.5 billion annually. The board’s schedule gives the applicants until February 16, 2027, to respond to requests for conditions such as Metra’s. The board has yet to decide whether to approve the merger or require either Chicago project.

Have a correction or information about this story? Contact Infraday.

The board has left the public hearing date open. Its schedule calls for final briefs by May 28, 2027.

Review the official next step →

Infraday+ research

Metra

Metra operates both Chicago-area commuter services addressed in the filing.

Primary sources

Additional reporting

You’re offline. Reconnect to load the latest Infraday updates.